HOW THE EFFECTIVENESS OF STATE CONTROL HAS CHANGED: CITIZENS' PERSPECTIVE

January 15, 2020, 09:30 – 11:00, Building 2, Floor 2, Lecture Room 138

Russia is vigorously reforming its regulatory and supervisory system with a purpose to protect the legally protected values (life, health, property, etc.), reduce administrative barriers and improve the quality of administration of its control and supervision functions. Traditionally, progress in this area is evaluated from the businesses’ and government bodies’ perspective, although this strategy fails to provide a comprehensive assessment of how well the public is protected against risks in the areas being supervised.

During the round table, an assessment of the governmental control effectiveness in 2018–2019 will be given from the citizens’ perspective, and prospects and priorities for improving the protection of legally protected values will be discussed.

Issues for Discussion

  • The control and supervision reform and degree of protection of legally protected values: is the dynamics noticeable?
  • Factors affecting the level of protection of legally protected values.
  • How effective are people’s complaints to regulatory and supervisory authorities: main problems.
  • Sociology and statistics: an integrated approach to assessing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.
  • Development prospects of alternative non-state control mechanisms: opportunities and limitations from citizens’ perspective.
  • Potential for increasing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.

Moderator

Speakers

  • Elena Dobrolyubova
    Elena Dobrolyubova

    Leading Research Fellow, Center for Public Administration Technologies, RANEPA

  • Elena Maslennikova
    Elena Maslennikova

    Leading Research Fellow, Center for Public Administration Technologies, RANEPA

  • Nadezhda Mashkova
    Nadezhda Mashkova

    Director of the Department for Control, Supervision and Permitting Activities, Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation

  • Vladimir Yuzhakov
    Vladimir Yuzhakov

    Director of the Center for Public Administration Technologies, RANEPA

Experts

  • Marina Bludyan
    Marina Bludyan

    First Vice-President, All-Russian Non-Governmental Organization of Small and Medium Business OPORA ROSSII

  • Kirill Grigoryev
    Kirill Grigoryev

    Deputy Head of the Analytical Department, Main Control Directorate of Moscow

  • Valentin Letunovsky
    Valentin Letunovsky

    Deputy Head, Control Directorate of the President of the Russian Federation

  • Svetlana Makovetskaya
    Svetlana Makovetskaya

    Director, Civic Analysis and Independent Research Center

  • Mikhail Orlov
    Mikhail Orlov

    State secretary, Deputy head, Russian Federal Service for Surveillance on Consumer Rights Protection and Human Wellbeing (Rospotrebnadzor)

  • Mikhail Pryadilnikov
    Mikhail Pryadilnikov

    Deputy Head, Analytical Center for the Government of the Russian Federation

  • Petr Shelishch
    Petr Shelishch

    Chairman, Union of Consumers of Russia

  • Rinat Yenikeyev
    Rinat Yenikeyev

    Head, Supervisory and Preventive Efforts Department, EMERCOM of Russia

Array
(
    [ACTIVE_TO] => 01/15/2020 11:00:00 am
    [~ACTIVE_TO] => 01/15/2020 11:00:00 am
    [ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/15/2020 09:30:00 am
    [~ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/15/2020 09:30:00 am
    [ID] => 21638
    [~ID] => 21638
    [NAME] => HOW THE EFFECTIVENESS OF STATE CONTROL HAS CHANGED: CITIZENS' PERSPECTIVE
    [~NAME] => HOW THE EFFECTIVENESS OF STATE CONTROL HAS CHANGED: CITIZENS' PERSPECTIVE
    [IBLOCK_ID] => 18
    [~IBLOCK_ID] => 18
    [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 378
    [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 378
    [DETAIL_TEXT] => 
    [~DETAIL_TEXT] => 
    [DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html
    [~DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html
    [PREVIEW_TEXT] => 

Russia is vigorously reforming its regulatory and supervisory system with a purpose to protect the legally protected values (life, health, property, etc.), reduce administrative barriers and improve the quality of administration of its control and supervision functions. Traditionally, progress in this area is evaluated from the businesses’ and government bodies’ perspective, although this strategy fails to provide a comprehensive assessment of how well the public is protected against risks in the areas being supervised.

During the round table, an assessment of the governmental control effectiveness in 2018–2019 will be given from the citizens’ perspective, and prospects and priorities for improving the protection of legally protected values will be discussed.

[~PREVIEW_TEXT] =>

Russia is vigorously reforming its regulatory and supervisory system with a purpose to protect the legally protected values (life, health, property, etc.), reduce administrative barriers and improve the quality of administration of its control and supervision functions. Traditionally, progress in this area is evaluated from the businesses’ and government bodies’ perspective, although this strategy fails to provide a comprehensive assessment of how well the public is protected against risks in the areas being supervised.

During the round table, an assessment of the governmental control effectiveness in 2018–2019 will be given from the citizens’ perspective, and prospects and priorities for improving the protection of legally protected values will be discussed.

[PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html [~PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/21/2020 03:18:36 pm [~TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/21/2020 03:18:36 pm [LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [~LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/15-january/how-the-efficiency-of-state-control-has-changed-citizens-point-of-view/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/15-january/how-the-efficiency-of-state-control-has-changed-citizens-point-of-view/ [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => how-the-efficiency-of-state-control-has-changed-citizens-point-of-view [~CODE] => how-the-efficiency-of-state-control-has-changed-citizens-point-of-view [EXTERNAL_ID] => 21638 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 21638 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => program [~IBLOCK_CODE] => program [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [LID] => en [~LID] => en [NAV_RESULT] => [DISPLAY_ACTIVE_FROM] => 15 January 2020 [IPROPERTY_VALUES] => Array ( ) [FIELDS] => Array ( [ACTIVE_TO] => 01/15/2020 11:00:00 am [ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/15/2020 09:30:00 am ) [PROPERTIES] => Array ( [QUESTIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 50 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 10 [CODE] => QUESTIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 12 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 120309 [VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => <ul class="style-prog-list"> <li>The control and supervision reform and degree of protection of legally protected values: is the dynamics noticeable?</li> <li>Factors affecting the level of protection of legally protected values.</li> <li>How effective are people’s complaints to regulatory and supervisory authorities: main problems.</li> <li>Sociology and statistics: an integrated approach to assessing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.</li> <li>Development prospects of alternative non-state control mechanisms: opportunities and limitations from citizens’ perspective.</li> <li>Potential for increasing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.</li> </ul> <br> [TYPE] => HTML ) [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] =>
  • The control and supervision reform and degree of protection of legally protected values: is the dynamics noticeable?
  • Factors affecting the level of protection of legally protected values.
  • How effective are people’s complaints to regulatory and supervisory authorities: main problems.
  • Sociology and statistics: an integrated approach to assessing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.
  • Development prospects of alternative non-state control mechanisms: opportunities and limitations from citizens’ perspective.
  • Potential for increasing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.

[TYPE] => HTML ) [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) ) [TYPE] => Array ( [ID] => 51 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Тип мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 20 [CODE] => TYPE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 13 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 139477 [VALUE] => Expert Discussion [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => Expert Discussion [VALUE_XML_ID] => 2 [VALUE_SORT] => 200 [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 7 [~VALUE] => Expert Discussion [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Тип мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LOCATION] => Array ( [ID] => 54 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 30 [CODE] => LOCATION [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 19 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 120315 [VALUE] => Building 2, Floor 2, Lecture Room 138 [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Building 2, Floor 2, Lecture Room 138 [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MODERATORS] => Array ( [ID] => 52 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:56 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Модераторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 40 [CODE] => MODERATORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 14 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 129343 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 22216 [NAME] => Yekaterina Salugina-Sorokovaya [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/yekaterina-salugina-sorokovaya/ [POSITION] => Director, Regulatory Policy Department, government of the Russian Federation [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 22216 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [~NAME] => Модераторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORTS] => Array ( [ID] => 68 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:25 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Ключевой доклад [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 50 [CODE] => KEYREPORTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевой доклад [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PARTICIPANTS] => Array ( [ID] => 53 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:16:15 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Экперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 60 [CODE] => PARTICIPANTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 15 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 120312 [1] => 120313 [2] => 120314 [3] => 124578 [4] => 131639 [5] => 131640 [6] => 131641 [7] => 131642 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 5066 [NAME] => Marina Bludyan [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/marina-bludyan/ [POSITION] => First Vice-President, All-Russian Non-Governmental Organization of Small and Medium Business OPORA ROSSII [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 8409 ) [1] => Array ( [ID] => 21826 [NAME] => Kirill Grigoryev [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/kirill-grigoryev/ [POSITION] => Deputy Head of the Analytical Department, Main Control Directorate of Moscow [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [2] => Array ( [ID] => 7807 [NAME] => Valentin Letunovsky [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/valentin-letunovskiy/ [POSITION] => Deputy Head, Control Directorate of the President of the Russian Federation [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [3] => Array ( [ID] => 16416 [NAME] => Svetlana Makovetskaya [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/svetlana-makovetskaya/ [POSITION] => Director, Civic Analysis and Independent Research Center [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 42195 ) [4] => Array ( [ID] => 22308 [NAME] => Mikhail Orlov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mikhail-orlov/ [POSITION] => State secretary, Deputy head, Russian Federal Service for Surveillance on Consumer Rights Protection and Human Wellbeing (Rospotrebnadzor) [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [5] => Array ( [ID] => 3562 [NAME] => Mikhail Pryadilnikov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mikhail-pryadilnikov/ [POSITION] => Deputy Head, Analytical Center for the Government of the Russian Federation [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 8707 ) [6] => Array ( [ID] => 21825 [NAME] => Petr Shelishch [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/petr-shelishch/ [POSITION] => Chairman, Union of Consumers of Russia [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [7] => Array ( [ID] => 22323 [NAME] => Rinat Yenikeyev [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/rinat-yenikeyev/ [POSITION] => Head, Supervisory and Preventive Efforts Department, EMERCOM of Russia [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 5066 [1] => 21826 [2] => 7807 [3] => 16416 [4] => 22308 [5] => 3562 [6] => 21825 [7] => 22323 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => ) [~NAME] => Экперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MEMBERS] => Array ( [ID] => 69 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:19 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Участники [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 70 [CODE] => MEMBERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS] => Array ( [ID] => 72 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:13 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Участники и эксперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 80 [CODE] => MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники и эксперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORT_MODERATOR] => Array ( [ID] => 115 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:28 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Ключевой доклад/модератор [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 90 [CODE] => KEYREPORT_MODERATOR [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевой доклад/модератор [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SAY_HIS] => Array ( [ID] => 246 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-15 23:30:57 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Приветствие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 91 [CODE] => SAY_HIS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Приветствие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SPEECH] => Array ( [ID] => 134 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:48 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Выступления [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 100 [CODE] => SPEECH [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Выступления [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [DISCUSS_MEMBERS] => Array ( [ID] => 226 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:36:04 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Участники дискуссии [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 101 [CODE] => DISCUSS_MEMBERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники дискуссии [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [AUTHORS] => Array ( [ID] => 227 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:37:12 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Авторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 102 [CODE] => AUTHORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Авторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LECTORS] => Array ( [ID] => 228 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:38:09 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Лекторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 103 [CODE] => LECTORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Лекторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PRESENTATIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 229 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:38:40 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Презентация [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 104 [CODE] => PRESENTATIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Презентация [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SPEAKERS] => Array ( [ID] => 230 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 11:26:55 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Спикеры [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 105 [CODE] => SPEAKERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 124581 [1] => 125357 [2] => 126586 [3] => 130389 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 15905 [NAME] => Elena Dobrolyubova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/elena-dobrolubova/ [POSITION] => Leading Research Fellow, Center for Public Administration Technologies, RANEPA [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [1] => Array ( [ID] => 15907 [NAME] => Elena Maslennikova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/elena-maslennikova/ [POSITION] => Leading Research Fellow, Center for Public Administration Technologies, RANEPA [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 42238 ) [2] => Array ( [ID] => 15075 [NAME] => Nadezhda Mashkova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nadezhda-mashkova/ [POSITION] => Director of the Department for Control, Supervision and Permitting Activities, Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37146 ) [3] => Array ( [ID] => 15037 [NAME] => Vladimir Yuzhakov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/vladimir-yuzhakov/ [POSITION] => Director of the Center for Public Administration Technologies, RANEPA [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37147 ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 15905 [1] => 15907 [2] => 15075 [3] => 15037 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => ) [~NAME] => Спикеры [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SUBTITLE] => Array ( [ID] => 74 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:19:10 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Подзаголовок [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 110 [CODE] => SUBTITLE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Подзаголовок [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MSP_REPRESENTATIVES] => Array ( [ID] => 78 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:11 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Представители МСП [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 120 [CODE] => MSP_REPRESENTATIVES [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => [TYPE] => HTML ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Представители МСП [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => [TYPE] => HTML ) ) [MEDIA_LINK] => Array ( [ID] => 135 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-16 21:02:27 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Медиаматериалы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 130 [CODE] => MEDIA_LINK [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 36 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 139478 [VALUE] => 24394 [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => 24394 [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Медиаматериалы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [CALENDAR] => Array ( [ID] => 131 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Календарь [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 140 [CODE] => CALENDAR [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Календарь [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [EVENT_INFO] => Array ( [ID] => 132 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Информационное событие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 150 [CODE] => EVENT_INFO [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Информационное событие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [CHANGE] => Array ( [ID] => 133 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Изменение [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 160 [CODE] => CHANGE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Изменение [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LANGUAGES] => Array ( [ID] => 224 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:26:52 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Рабочие языки [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 170 [CODE] => LANGUAGES [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 139479 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Russian ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => Array ( [0] => Russian ) [VALUE_XML_ID] => Array ( [0] => affb1430ade1dabb9b750ff1961d2505 ) [VALUE_SORT] => Array ( [0] => 10 ) [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => Array ( [0] => 54 ) [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Russian ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [~NAME] => Рабочие языки [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [INVITATION_ONLY] => Array ( [ID] => 225 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 18:34:07 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 180 [CODE] => INVITATION_ONLY [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PREMIUM_ONLY] => Array ( [ID] => 233 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 18:34:07 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ» [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 190 [CODE] => PREMIUM_ONLY [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ» [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYNOTE_FILE] => Array ( [ID] => 239 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2019-01-14 21:47:41 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Доклад [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 200 [CODE] => KEYNOTE_FILE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => F [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => pdf [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Доклад [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [OPENINGS] => Array ( [ID] => 241 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-05 18:10:45 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Открытие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 500 [CODE] => OPENINGS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Открытие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [EVENT_CATEGORY] => Array ( [ID] => 298 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2019-12-27 11:18:04 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Категория мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 500 [CODE] => EVENT_CATEGORY [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 139480 [VALUE] => Scientific Expert Program [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => Scientific Expert Program [VALUE_XML_ID] => #7fa6cb,#333333 [VALUE_SORT] => 200 [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 97 [~VALUE] => Scientific Expert Program [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Категория мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORT2S] => Array ( [ID] => 306 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2019-12-31 10:17:49 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Ключевые выступления [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 500 [CODE] => KEYREPORT2S [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевые выступления [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) ) [DISPLAY_PROPERTIES] => Array ( [QUESTIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 50 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 10 [CODE] => QUESTIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 12 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 120309 [VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => <ul class="style-prog-list"> <li>The control and supervision reform and degree of protection of legally protected values: is the dynamics noticeable?</li> <li>Factors affecting the level of protection of legally protected values.</li> <li>How effective are people’s complaints to regulatory and supervisory authorities: main problems.</li> <li>Sociology and statistics: an integrated approach to assessing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.</li> <li>Development prospects of alternative non-state control mechanisms: opportunities and limitations from citizens’ perspective.</li> <li>Potential for increasing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.</li> </ul> <br> [TYPE] => HTML ) [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] =>
  • The control and supervision reform and degree of protection of legally protected values: is the dynamics noticeable?
  • Factors affecting the level of protection of legally protected values.
  • How effective are people’s complaints to regulatory and supervisory authorities: main problems.
  • Sociology and statistics: an integrated approach to assessing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.
  • Development prospects of alternative non-state control mechanisms: opportunities and limitations from citizens’ perspective.
  • Potential for increasing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.

[TYPE] => HTML ) [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [DISPLAY_VALUE] =>
  • The control and supervision reform and degree of protection of legally protected values: is the dynamics noticeable?
  • Factors affecting the level of protection of legally protected values.
  • How effective are people’s complaints to regulatory and supervisory authorities: main problems.
  • Sociology and statistics: an integrated approach to assessing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.
  • Development prospects of alternative non-state control mechanisms: opportunities and limitations from citizens’ perspective.
  • Potential for increasing the effectiveness of control and supervision activities.

) [LOCATION] => Array ( [ID] => 54 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 30 [CODE] => LOCATION [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 19 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 120315 [VALUE] => Building 2, Floor 2, Lecture Room 138 [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Building 2, Floor 2, Lecture Room 138 [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Building 2, Floor 2, Lecture Room 138 ) [MODERATORS] => Array ( [ID] => 52 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:56 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Модераторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 40 [CODE] => MODERATORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 14 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 129343 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 22216 ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 22216 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [~NAME] => Модераторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Yekaterina Salugina-Sorokovaya [LINK_ELEMENT_VALUE] => Array ( [22216] => Array ( [ID] => 22216 [~ID] => 22216 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Yekaterina Salugina-Sorokovaya [~NAME] => Yekaterina Salugina-Sorokovaya [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/yekaterina-salugina-sorokovaya/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/yekaterina-salugina-sorokovaya/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => yekaterina-salugina-sorokovaya [~CODE] => yekaterina-salugina-sorokovaya [EXTERNAL_ID] => 22216 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 22216 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) ) ) [PARTICIPANTS] => Array ( [ID] => 53 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:16:15 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Экперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 60 [CODE] => PARTICIPANTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 15 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 120312 [1] => 120313 [2] => 120314 [3] => 124578 [4] => 131639 [5] => 131640 [6] => 131641 [7] => 131642 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 5066 [1] => 21826 [2] => 7807 [3] => 16416 [4] => 22308 [5] => 3562 [6] => 21825 [7] => 22323 ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 5066 [1] => 21826 [2] => 7807 [3] => 16416 [4] => 22308 [5] => 3562 [6] => 21825 [7] => 22323 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => ) [~NAME] => Экперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Marina Bludyan [1] => Kirill Grigoryev [2] => Valentin Letunovsky [3] => Svetlana Makovetskaya [4] => Mikhail Orlov [5] => Mikhail Pryadilnikov [6] => Petr Shelishch [7] => Rinat Yenikeyev ) [LINK_ELEMENT_VALUE] => Array ( [5066] => Array ( [ID] => 5066 [~ID] => 5066 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Marina Bludyan [~NAME] => Marina Bludyan [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/marina-bludyan/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/marina-bludyan/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 8409 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 8409 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => marina-bludyan [~CODE] => marina-bludyan [EXTERNAL_ID] => 5066 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 5066 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [21826] => Array ( [ID] => 21826 [~ID] => 21826 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Kirill Grigoryev [~NAME] => Kirill Grigoryev [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/kirill-grigoryev/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/kirill-grigoryev/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => kirill-grigoryev [~CODE] => kirill-grigoryev [EXTERNAL_ID] => 21826 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 21826 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [7807] => Array ( [ID] => 7807 [~ID] => 7807 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Valentin Letunovsky [~NAME] => Valentin Letunovsky [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/valentin-letunovskiy/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/valentin-letunovskiy/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => valentin-letunovskiy [~CODE] => valentin-letunovskiy [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7807 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7807 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [16416] => Array ( [ID] => 16416 [~ID] => 16416 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Svetlana Makovetskaya [~NAME] => Svetlana Makovetskaya [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/svetlana-makovetskaya/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/svetlana-makovetskaya/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 42195 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 42195 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => svetlana-makovetskaya [~CODE] => svetlana-makovetskaya [EXTERNAL_ID] => 16416 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 16416 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 248 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 248 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [22308] => Array ( [ID] => 22308 [~ID] => 22308 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Mikhail Orlov [~NAME] => Mikhail Orlov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mikhail-orlov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mikhail-orlov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => mikhail-orlov [~CODE] => mikhail-orlov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 22308 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 22308 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [3562] => Array ( [ID] => 3562 [~ID] => 3562 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Mikhail Pryadilnikov [~NAME] => Mikhail Pryadilnikov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mikhail-pryadilnikov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/mikhail-pryadilnikov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 8707 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 8707 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => mikhail-pryadilnikov [~CODE] => mikhail-pryadilnikov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 3562 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 3562 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [21825] => Array ( [ID] => 21825 [~ID] => 21825 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Petr Shelishch [~NAME] => Petr Shelishch [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/petr-shelishch/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/petr-shelishch/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => petr-shelishch [~CODE] => petr-shelishch [EXTERNAL_ID] => 21825 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 21825 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [22323] => Array ( [ID] => 22323 [~ID] => 22323 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Rinat Yenikeyev [~NAME] => Rinat Yenikeyev [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/rinat-yenikeyev/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/rinat-yenikeyev/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => rinat-yenikeyev [~CODE] => rinat-yenikeyev [EXTERNAL_ID] => 22323 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 22323 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 348 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) ) ) ) [IBLOCK] => Array ( [ID] => 18 [~ID] => 18 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/16/2020 12:52:35 pm [~TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/16/2020 12:52:35 pm [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [LID] => en [~LID] => en [CODE] => program [~CODE] => program [NAME] => Forum program [~NAME] => Forum program [ACTIVE] => Y [~ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 9000 [~SORT] => 9000 [LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [~LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/#ELEMENT_CODE#/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/#ELEMENT_CODE#/ [SECTION_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/ [~SECTION_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/ [CANONICAL_PAGE_URL] => [~CANONICAL_PAGE_URL] => [PICTURE] => [~PICTURE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [DESCRIPTION_TYPE] => text [~DESCRIPTION_TYPE] => text [RSS_TTL] => 24 [~RSS_TTL] => 24 [RSS_ACTIVE] => Y [~RSS_ACTIVE] => Y [RSS_FILE_ACTIVE] => N [~RSS_FILE_ACTIVE] => N [RSS_FILE_LIMIT] => [~RSS_FILE_LIMIT] => [RSS_FILE_DAYS] => [~RSS_FILE_DAYS] => [RSS_YANDEX_ACTIVE] => N [~RSS_YANDEX_ACTIVE] => N [XML_ID] => 900 [~XML_ID] => 900 [TMP_ID] => cd00f8d356e8ae6a7d709487233896c1 [~TMP_ID] => cd00f8d356e8ae6a7d709487233896c1 [INDEX_ELEMENT] => Y [~INDEX_ELEMENT] => Y [INDEX_SECTION] => Y [~INDEX_SECTION] => Y [WORKFLOW] => N [~WORKFLOW] => N [BIZPROC] => N [~BIZPROC] => N [SECTION_CHOOSER] => L [~SECTION_CHOOSER] => L [LIST_MODE] => [~LIST_MODE] => [RIGHTS_MODE] => S [~RIGHTS_MODE] => S [SECTION_PROPERTY] => N [~SECTION_PROPERTY] => N [PROPERTY_INDEX] => N [~PROPERTY_INDEX] => N [VERSION] => 1 [~VERSION] => 1 [LAST_CONV_ELEMENT] => 0 [~LAST_CONV_ELEMENT] => 0 [SOCNET_GROUP_ID] => [~SOCNET_GROUP_ID] => [EDIT_FILE_BEFORE] => [~EDIT_FILE_BEFORE] => [EDIT_FILE_AFTER] => [~EDIT_FILE_AFTER] => [SECTIONS_NAME] => Разделы [~SECTIONS_NAME] => Разделы [SECTION_NAME] => Раздел [~SECTION_NAME] => Раздел [ELEMENTS_NAME] => Элементы [~ELEMENTS_NAME] => Элементы [ELEMENT_NAME] => Элемент [~ELEMENT_NAME] => Элемент [EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [SERVER_NAME] => en.gaidarforum.ru [~SERVER_NAME] => en.gaidarforum.ru ) [SECTION] => Array ( [PATH] => Array ( ) ) [SECTION_URL] => [META_TAGS] => Array ( [TITLE] => HOW THE EFFECTIVENESS OF STATE CONTROL HAS CHANGED: CITIZENS' PERSPECTIVE [ELEMENT_CHAIN] => HOW THE EFFECTIVENESS OF STATE CONTROL HAS CHANGED: CITIZENS' PERSPECTIVE [BROWSER_TITLE] => [KEYWORDS] => [DESCRIPTION] => ) [EXPERTSTYPES] => Array ( [0] => OPENINGS [1] => SAY_HIS [2] => MODERATORS [3] => KEYREPORT_MODERATOR [4] => KEYREPORTS [5] => KEYREPORT2S [6] => SPEAKERS [7] => SPEECH [8] => PRESENTATIONS [9] => MEMBERS [10] => PARTICIPANTS [11] => MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS [12] => DISCUSS_MEMBERS [13] => AUTHORS [14] => LECTORS ) [DATE_EVENT] => January 15, 2020 [START_TIME] => 09:30 [END_TIME] => 11:00 [TIME_EVENT] => January 15 [OGDESC] =>

Russia is vigorously reforming its regulatory and supervisory system with a purpose to protect the legally protected values (life, health, property, etc.), reduce administrative barriers and improve the quality of administration of its control and supervision functions. Traditionally, progress in this area is evaluated from the businesses’ and government bodies’ perspective, although this strategy fails to provide a comprehensive assessment of how well the public is protected against risks in the areas being supervised.

During the round table, an assessment of the governmental control effectiveness in 2018–2019 will be given from the citizens’ perspective, and prospects and priorities for improving the protection of legally protected values will be discussed.

)