EFFICIENT BUDGET EXPENDITURE AS A MIRROR OF EFFICIENT PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION

January 16, 2018, 10:00 – 11:30, Building 5, Floor 5, Assembly Hall

What is public administration today? How does the budgetary system operate?

At the federal level alone there are 53 ministries and agencies (16 ministries, 19 services, 18 agencies), 373,600 people who administer more than 66% of the federal budget expenditure and at the same time generate a growing budgetary network. a multi-step public administration system gives rise to challenges within the system, reduces the control over the use of budgetary resources, and blurs responsibility for functions entrusted.

Issues for Discussion

  • What should be changed for the public administration system to operate efficiently? 
  • Should the activities of a public servant be assessed? Should the system of his/her financial incentives be changed?
  • How to reduce violations and ineffective expenses when using public resources?
  • How to improve the quality of exercise of powers delegated to regions and municipalities? Should they become own powers of regions with income sources redistribution or exchange for other expenditure powers?

Moderator

  • Andrei Makarov
    Andrei Makarov

    Chairman of the State Duma Committee on Budget and Taxes

Speakers

  • Tatyana Golikova
    Tatyana Golikova

    Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation

  • Anton Siluanov
    Anton Siluanov

    First Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation – Minister of Finance of the Russian Federation

Experts

Array
(
    [ACTIVE_TO] => 01/16/2018 11:30:00 am
    [~ACTIVE_TO] => 01/16/2018 11:30:00 am
    [ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/16/2018 10:00:00 am
    [~ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/16/2018 10:00:00 am
    [ID] => 7285
    [~ID] => 7285
    [NAME] => EFFICIENT BUDGET EXPENDITURE AS A MIRROR OF EFFICIENT PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
    [~NAME] => EFFICIENT BUDGET EXPENDITURE AS A MIRROR OF EFFICIENT PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
    [IBLOCK_ID] => 18
    [~IBLOCK_ID] => 18
    [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 216
    [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 216
    [DETAIL_TEXT] => 

What is public administration today? How does the budgetary system operate?

At the federal level alone there are 53 ministries and agencies (16 ministries, 19 services, 18 agencies), 373,600 people who administer more than 66% of the federal budget expenditure and at the same time generate a growing budgetary network. a multi-step public administration system gives rise to challenges within the system, reduces the control over the use of budgetary resources, and blurs responsibility for functions entrusted.

[~DETAIL_TEXT] =>

What is public administration today? How does the budgetary system operate?

At the federal level alone there are 53 ministries and agencies (16 ministries, 19 services, 18 agencies), 373,600 people who administer more than 66% of the federal budget expenditure and at the same time generate a growing budgetary network. a multi-step public administration system gives rise to challenges within the system, reduces the control over the use of budgetary resources, and blurs responsibility for functions entrusted.

[DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html [~DETAIL_TEXT_TYPE] => html [PREVIEW_TEXT] =>

What is public administration today? How does the budgetary system operate?

At the federal level alone there are 53 ministries and agencies (16 ministries, 19 services, 18 agencies), 373,600 people who administer more than 66% of the federal budget expenditure and at the same time generate a growing budgetary network. a multi-step public administration system gives rise to challenges within the system, reduces the control over the use of budgetary resources, and blurs responsibility for functions entrusted.

[~PREVIEW_TEXT] =>

What is public administration today? How does the budgetary system operate?

At the federal level alone there are 53 ministries and agencies (16 ministries, 19 services, 18 agencies), 373,600 people who administer more than 66% of the federal budget expenditure and at the same time generate a growing budgetary network. a multi-step public administration system gives rise to challenges within the system, reduces the control over the use of budgetary resources, and blurs responsibility for functions entrusted.

[PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html [~PREVIEW_TEXT_TYPE] => html [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/17/2018 05:00:28 am [~TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/17/2018 05:00:28 am [LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [~LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/16-january/efficient-budget-expenditure-as-a-mirror-of-efficient-public-administration/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /program/16-january/efficient-budget-expenditure-as-a-mirror-of-efficient-public-administration/ [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => efficient-budget-expenditure-as-a-mirror-of-efficient-public-administration [~CODE] => efficient-budget-expenditure-as-a-mirror-of-efficient-public-administration [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7285 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7285 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => program [~IBLOCK_CODE] => program [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [LID] => en [~LID] => en [NAV_RESULT] => [DISPLAY_ACTIVE_FROM] => 16 January 2018 [IPROPERTY_VALUES] => Array ( ) [FIELDS] => Array ( [ACTIVE_TO] => 01/16/2018 11:30:00 am [ACTIVE_FROM] => 01/16/2018 10:00:00 am ) [PROPERTIES] => Array ( [QUESTIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 50 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 10 [CODE] => QUESTIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 12 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 26825 [VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => <ul type="disc" class="style-prog-list"> <li>What should be changed for the public administration system to operate efficiently? </li> <li>Should the activities of a public servant be assessed? Should the system of his/her financial incentives be changed?</li> <li>How to reduce violations and ineffective expenses when using public resources?</li> <li>How to improve the quality of exercise of powers delegated to regions and municipalities? Should they become own powers of regions with income sources redistribution or exchange for other expenditure powers?</li> </ul> [TYPE] => HTML ) [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] =>
  • What should be changed for the public administration system to operate efficiently? 
  • Should the activities of a public servant be assessed? Should the system of his/her financial incentives be changed?
  • How to reduce violations and ineffective expenses when using public resources?
  • How to improve the quality of exercise of powers delegated to regions and municipalities? Should they become own powers of regions with income sources redistribution or exchange for other expenditure powers?
[TYPE] => HTML ) [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) ) [TYPE] => Array ( [ID] => 51 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Тип мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 20 [CODE] => TYPE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 13 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 42508 [VALUE] => Open Dialogue [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => Open Dialogue [VALUE_XML_ID] => 16 [VALUE_SORT] => 800 [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 58 [~VALUE] => Open Dialogue [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Тип мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LOCATION] => Array ( [ID] => 54 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 30 [CODE] => LOCATION [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 19 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 25976 [VALUE] => Building 5, Floor 5, Assembly Hall [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Building 5, Floor 5, Assembly Hall [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MODERATORS] => Array ( [ID] => 52 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:56 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Модераторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 40 [CODE] => MODERATORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 14 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 25975 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 2643 [NAME] => Andrei Makarov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-makarov/ [POSITION] => Chairman of the State Duma Committee on Budget and Taxes [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37016 ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 2643 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [~NAME] => Модераторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORTS] => Array ( [ID] => 68 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:25 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Ключевой доклад [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 50 [CODE] => KEYREPORTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевой доклад [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PARTICIPANTS] => Array ( [ID] => 53 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:16:15 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Экперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 60 [CODE] => PARTICIPANTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 15 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 26891 [1] => 26892 [2] => 26893 [3] => 26900 [4] => 26901 [5] => 26919 [6] => 26920 [7] => 26921 [8] => 26922 [9] => 26923 [10] => 26928 [11] => 29203 [12] => 29204 [13] => 32748 [14] => 35081 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 7700 [NAME] => Alexey Chichkanov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexey-chichkanov/ [POSITION] => Executive Vice-President, Gazprombank JSC [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 14293 ) [1] => Array ( [ID] => 8143 [NAME] => Sholban Kara-ool [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/sholban-kara-ool/ [POSITION] => Head, Republic of Tyva [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 17093 ) [2] => Array ( [ID] => 3498 [NAME] => Natalia Komarova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nataliya-komarova/ [POSITION] => Governor of the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Area - Yugra [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37018 ) [3] => Array ( [ID] => 7397 [NAME] => Oleg Kuvshinnikov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/oleg-kuvshinnikov/ [POSITION] => Governor, Vologodsk Region [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13676 ) [4] => Array ( [ID] => 2554 [NAME] => Yaroslav Kuzminov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/yaroslav-kuzminov/ [POSITION] => Rector, National Research University Higher School of Economics [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 14538 ) [5] => Array ( [ID] => 7398 [NAME] => Nikolai Lyubimov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nikolay-lubimov/ [POSITION] => Governor of Ryazan Region [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37020 ) [6] => Array ( [ID] => 1184 [NAME] => [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => [POSITION] => [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [7] => Array ( [ID] => 2537 [NAME] => [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => [POSITION] => [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [8] => Array ( [ID] => 3076 [NAME] => Andrey Nikitin [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-nikitin/ [POSITION] => Governor of Novgorod Region [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37003 ) [9] => Array ( [ID] => 2535 [NAME] => Svetlana Orlova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/svetlana-orlova/ [POSITION] => Governor, Vladimir Region [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3081 ) [10] => Array ( [ID] => 7399 [NAME] => Andrey Travnikov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-travnikov/ [POSITION] => Acting Governor, Novosibirsk Region [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13671 ) [11] => Array ( [ID] => 7718 [NAME] => Alexander Tsibulskiy [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexander-tsibulskiy/ [POSITION] => Acting Governor, Nenets Autonomous Okrug [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13684 ) [12] => Array ( [ID] => 7400 [NAME] => Alexander Uss [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexander-uss/ [POSITION] => Acting Governor, Krasnoyarsk Territory [DONOTLINK] => Y [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13672 ) [13] => Array ( [ID] => 2702 [NAME] => [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => [POSITION] => [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => ) [14] => Array ( [ID] => 1202 [NAME] => Sergey Zhvachkin [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/sergey-zhvachkin/ [POSITION] => Governor of Tomsk Region [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37067 ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => [8] => [9] => [10] => [11] => [12] => [13] => [14] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 7700 [1] => 8143 [2] => 3498 [3] => 7397 [4] => 2554 [5] => 7398 [6] => 1184 [7] => 2537 [8] => 3076 [9] => 2535 [10] => 7399 [11] => 7718 [12] => 7400 [13] => 2702 [14] => 1202 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => [8] => [9] => [10] => [11] => [12] => [13] => [14] => ) [~NAME] => Экперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MEMBERS] => Array ( [ID] => 69 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:19 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Участники [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 70 [CODE] => MEMBERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS] => Array ( [ID] => 72 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:13 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Участники и эксперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 80 [CODE] => MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники и эксперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYREPORT_MODERATOR] => Array ( [ID] => 115 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:28 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Ключевой доклад/модератор [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 90 [CODE] => KEYREPORT_MODERATOR [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Ключевой доклад/модератор [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SAY_HIS] => Array ( [ID] => 246 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-15 23:30:57 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Приветствие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 91 [CODE] => SAY_HIS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Приветствие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SPEECH] => Array ( [ID] => 134 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:18:48 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Выступления [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 100 [CODE] => SPEECH [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Выступления [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [DISCUSS_MEMBERS] => Array ( [ID] => 226 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:36:04 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Участники дискуссии [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 101 [CODE] => DISCUSS_MEMBERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Участники дискуссии [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [AUTHORS] => Array ( [ID] => 227 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:37:12 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Авторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 102 [CODE] => AUTHORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Авторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LECTORS] => Array ( [ID] => 228 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:38:09 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Лекторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 103 [CODE] => LECTORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 8 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Лекторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PRESENTATIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 229 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:38:40 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Презентация [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 104 [CODE] => PRESENTATIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Презентация [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SPEAKERS] => Array ( [ID] => 230 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 11:26:55 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Спикеры [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 105 [CODE] => SPEAKERS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 26847 [1] => 26873 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Array ( [ID] => 2647 [NAME] => Tatyana Golikova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/tatyana-golikova/ [POSITION] => Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 54005 ) [1] => Array ( [ID] => 1213 [NAME] => Anton Siluanov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/anton-siluanov/ [POSITION] => First Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation – Minister of Finance of the Russian Federation [DONOTLINK] => [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 54010 ) ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 2647 [1] => 1213 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [~NAME] => Спикеры [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [SUBTITLE] => Array ( [ID] => 74 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:19:10 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Подзаголовок [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 110 [CODE] => SUBTITLE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Подзаголовок [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [MSP_REPRESENTATIVES] => Array ( [ID] => 78 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:11 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Представители МСП [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 120 [CODE] => MSP_REPRESENTATIVES [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => [TYPE] => HTML ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Представители МСП [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => [TYPE] => HTML ) ) [MEDIA_LINK] => Array ( [ID] => 135 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-16 21:02:27 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Медиаматериалы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 130 [CODE] => MEDIA_LINK [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 36 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 42256 [VALUE] => 8718 [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => 8718 [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Медиаматериалы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [CALENDAR] => Array ( [ID] => 131 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Календарь [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 140 [CODE] => CALENDAR [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 42509 [VALUE] => Да [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => Да [VALUE_XML_ID] => cdcbcf72d67def380b63dd8ba1dd146d [VALUE_SORT] => 500 [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 39 [~VALUE] => Да [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Календарь [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [EVENT_INFO] => Array ( [ID] => 132 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Информационное событие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 150 [CODE] => EVENT_INFO [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Информационное событие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [CHANGE] => Array ( [ID] => 133 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:20:36 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Изменение [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 160 [CODE] => CHANGE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Изменение [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [LANGUAGES] => Array ( [ID] => 224 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:26:52 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Рабочие языки [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 170 [CODE] => LANGUAGES [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 42511 [1] => 42510 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Russian [1] => English ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => Array ( [0] => Russian [1] => English ) [VALUE_XML_ID] => Array ( [0] => affb1430ade1dabb9b750ff1961d2505 [1] => 296b3d354b8509e4ce2133793442286c ) [VALUE_SORT] => Array ( [0] => 10 [1] => 30 ) [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => Array ( [0] => 54 [1] => 56 ) [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Russian [1] => English ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => ) [~NAME] => Рабочие языки [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [INVITATION_ONLY] => Array ( [ID] => 225 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 18:34:07 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 180 [CODE] => INVITATION_ONLY [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вход по индивидуальным приглашениям [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [PREMIUM_ONLY] => Array ( [ID] => 233 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-22 18:34:07 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ» [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 190 [CODE] => PREMIUM_ONLY [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => L [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => C [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 42513 [VALUE] => Да [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => Да [VALUE_XML_ID] => 765fa0f0c0520b2196c03d09c741f4f2 [VALUE_SORT] => 500 [VALUE_ENUM_ID] => 64 [~VALUE] => Да [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вход с бэйджами категории «ПРЕМИУМ» [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYNOTE_FILE] => Array ( [ID] => 239 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2019-01-14 21:47:41 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Доклад [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 200 [CODE] => KEYNOTE_FILE [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => F [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => pdf [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Доклад [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [OPENINGS] => Array ( [ID] => 241 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2018-01-05 18:10:45 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Открытие [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 500 [CODE] => OPENINGS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => [VALUE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Открытие [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => ) [KEYNOTE] => ) [DISPLAY_PROPERTIES] => Array ( [QUESTIONS] => Array ( [ID] => 50 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 10 [CODE] => QUESTIONS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 12 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => Y [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => HTML [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => Array ( [height] => 200 ) [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 26825 [VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] => <ul type="disc" class="style-prog-list"> <li>What should be changed for the public administration system to operate efficiently? </li> <li>Should the activities of a public servant be assessed? Should the system of his/her financial incentives be changed?</li> <li>How to reduce violations and ineffective expenses when using public resources?</li> <li>How to improve the quality of exercise of powers delegated to regions and municipalities? Should they become own powers of regions with income sources redistribution or exchange for other expenditure powers?</li> </ul> [TYPE] => HTML ) [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [TEXT] =>
  • What should be changed for the public administration system to operate efficiently? 
  • Should the activities of a public servant be assessed? Should the system of his/her financial incentives be changed?
  • How to reduce violations and ineffective expenses when using public resources?
  • How to improve the quality of exercise of powers delegated to regions and municipalities? Should they become own powers of regions with income sources redistribution or exchange for other expenditure powers?
[TYPE] => HTML ) [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Вопросы для обсуждения [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => Array ( [TYPE] => HTML [TEXT] => ) [DISPLAY_VALUE] =>
  • What should be changed for the public administration system to operate efficiently? 
  • Should the activities of a public servant be assessed? Should the system of his/her financial incentives be changed?
  • How to reduce violations and ineffective expenses when using public resources?
  • How to improve the quality of exercise of powers delegated to regions and municipalities? Should they become own powers of regions with income sources redistribution or exchange for other expenditure powers?
) [LOCATION] => Array ( [ID] => 54 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:14:00 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 30 [CODE] => LOCATION [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => S [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => N [XML_ID] => 19 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 0 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => 25976 [VALUE] => Building 5, Floor 5, Assembly Hall [DESCRIPTION] => [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Building 5, Floor 5, Assembly Hall [~DESCRIPTION] => [~NAME] => Место проведения мероприятия [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Building 5, Floor 5, Assembly Hall ) [MODERATORS] => Array ( [ID] => 52 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:15:56 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Модераторы [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 40 [CODE] => MODERATORS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 14 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 25975 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 2643 ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 2643 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => ) [~NAME] => Модераторы [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Andrei Makarov [LINK_ELEMENT_VALUE] => Array ( [2643] => Array ( [ID] => 2643 [~ID] => 2643 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Andrei Makarov [~NAME] => Andrei Makarov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-makarov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-makarov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37016 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37016 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => andrey-makarov [~CODE] => andrey-makarov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 2643 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 2643 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) ) ) [PARTICIPANTS] => Array ( [ID] => 53 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 2017-12-20 14:16:15 [IBLOCK_ID] => 18 [NAME] => Экперты [ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 60 [CODE] => PARTICIPANTS [DEFAULT_VALUE] => [PROPERTY_TYPE] => E [ROW_COUNT] => 1 [COL_COUNT] => 30 [LIST_TYPE] => L [MULTIPLE] => Y [XML_ID] => 15 [FILE_TYPE] => [MULTIPLE_CNT] => 5 [TMP_ID] => [LINK_IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [WITH_DESCRIPTION] => N [SEARCHABLE] => N [FILTRABLE] => N [IS_REQUIRED] => N [VERSION] => 1 [USER_TYPE] => [USER_TYPE_SETTINGS] => [HINT] => [PROPERTY_VALUE_ID] => Array ( [0] => 26891 [1] => 26892 [2] => 26893 [3] => 26900 [4] => 26901 [5] => 26919 [6] => 26920 [7] => 26921 [8] => 26922 [9] => 26923 [10] => 26928 [11] => 29203 [12] => 29204 [13] => 32748 [14] => 35081 ) [VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 7700 [1] => 8143 [2] => 3498 [3] => 7397 [4] => 2554 [5] => 7398 [6] => 1184 [7] => 2537 [8] => 3076 [9] => 2535 [10] => 7399 [11] => 7718 [12] => 7400 [13] => 2702 [14] => 1202 ) [DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => [8] => [9] => [10] => [11] => [12] => [13] => [14] => ) [VALUE_ENUM] => [VALUE_XML_ID] => [VALUE_SORT] => [~VALUE] => Array ( [0] => 7700 [1] => 8143 [2] => 3498 [3] => 7397 [4] => 2554 [5] => 7398 [6] => 1184 [7] => 2537 [8] => 3076 [9] => 2535 [10] => 7399 [11] => 7718 [12] => 7400 [13] => 2702 [14] => 1202 ) [~DESCRIPTION] => Array ( [0] => [1] => [2] => [3] => [4] => [5] => [6] => [7] => [8] => [9] => [10] => [11] => [12] => [13] => [14] => ) [~NAME] => Экперты [~DEFAULT_VALUE] => [DISPLAY_VALUE] => Array ( [0] => Alexey Chichkanov [1] => Sholban Kara-ool [2] => Natalia Komarova [3] => Oleg Kuvshinnikov [4] => Yaroslav Kuzminov [5] => Nikolai Lyubimov [6] => Andrey Nikitin [7] => Svetlana Orlova [8] => Andrey Travnikov [9] => Alexander Tsibulskiy [10] => Alexander Uss [11] => Sergey Zhvachkin ) [LINK_ELEMENT_VALUE] => Array ( [7700] => Array ( [ID] => 7700 [~ID] => 7700 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Alexey Chichkanov [~NAME] => Alexey Chichkanov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexey-chichkanov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexey-chichkanov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 14293 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 14293 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => alexey-chichkanov [~CODE] => alexey-chichkanov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7700 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7700 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [8143] => Array ( [ID] => 8143 [~ID] => 8143 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Sholban Kara-ool [~NAME] => Sholban Kara-ool [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/sholban-kara-ool/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/sholban-kara-ool/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 17093 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 17093 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => sholban-kara-ool [~CODE] => sholban-kara-ool [EXTERNAL_ID] => 8143 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 8143 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [3498] => Array ( [ID] => 3498 [~ID] => 3498 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Natalia Komarova [~NAME] => Natalia Komarova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nataliya-komarova/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nataliya-komarova/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37018 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37018 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => nataliya-komarova [~CODE] => nataliya-komarova [EXTERNAL_ID] => 3498 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 3498 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [7397] => Array ( [ID] => 7397 [~ID] => 7397 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Oleg Kuvshinnikov [~NAME] => Oleg Kuvshinnikov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/oleg-kuvshinnikov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/oleg-kuvshinnikov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13676 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13676 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => oleg-kuvshinnikov [~CODE] => oleg-kuvshinnikov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7397 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7397 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [2554] => Array ( [ID] => 2554 [~ID] => 2554 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Yaroslav Kuzminov [~NAME] => Yaroslav Kuzminov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/yaroslav-kuzminov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/yaroslav-kuzminov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 14538 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 14538 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => yaroslav-kuzminov [~CODE] => yaroslav-kuzminov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 2554 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 2554 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [7398] => Array ( [ID] => 7398 [~ID] => 7398 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Nikolai Lyubimov [~NAME] => Nikolai Lyubimov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nikolay-lubimov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/nikolay-lubimov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37020 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37020 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => nikolay-lubimov [~CODE] => nikolay-lubimov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7398 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7398 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [3076] => Array ( [ID] => 3076 [~ID] => 3076 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Andrey Nikitin [~NAME] => Andrey Nikitin [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-nikitin/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-nikitin/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37003 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37003 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => andrey-nikitin [~CODE] => andrey-nikitin [EXTERNAL_ID] => 3076 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 3076 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [2535] => Array ( [ID] => 2535 [~ID] => 2535 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Svetlana Orlova [~NAME] => Svetlana Orlova [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/svetlana-orlova/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/svetlana-orlova/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3081 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 3081 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => svetlana-orlova [~CODE] => svetlana-orlova [EXTERNAL_ID] => 2535 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 2535 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [7399] => Array ( [ID] => 7399 [~ID] => 7399 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Andrey Travnikov [~NAME] => Andrey Travnikov [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-travnikov/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/andrey-travnikov/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13671 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13671 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => andrey-travnikov [~CODE] => andrey-travnikov [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7399 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7399 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [7718] => Array ( [ID] => 7718 [~ID] => 7718 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Alexander Tsibulskiy [~NAME] => Alexander Tsibulskiy [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexander-tsibulskiy/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexander-tsibulskiy/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13684 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13684 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => alexander-tsibulskiy [~CODE] => alexander-tsibulskiy [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7718 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7718 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [7400] => Array ( [ID] => 7400 [~ID] => 7400 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Alexander Uss [~NAME] => Alexander Uss [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexander-uss/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/alexander-uss/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13672 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 13672 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => alexander-uss [~CODE] => alexander-uss [EXTERNAL_ID] => 7400 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 7400 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 169 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) [1202] => Array ( [ID] => 1202 [~ID] => 1202 [IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [~IBLOCK_ID] => 17 [NAME] => Sergey Zhvachkin [~NAME] => Sergey Zhvachkin [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/sergey-zhvachkin/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => /experts/sergey-zhvachkin/ [PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37067 [~PREVIEW_PICTURE] => 37067 [DETAIL_PICTURE] => [~DETAIL_PICTURE] => [SORT] => 500 [~SORT] => 500 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [CODE] => sergey-zhvachkin [~CODE] => sergey-zhvachkin [EXTERNAL_ID] => 1202 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 1202 [IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [~IBLOCK_SECTION_ID] => 168 [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [~IBLOCK_CODE] => experts [IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [~IBLOCK_EXTERNAL_ID] => 800 [LID] => en [~LID] => en ) ) ) ) [IBLOCK] => Array ( [ID] => 18 [~ID] => 18 [TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/17/2019 12:57:10 am [~TIMESTAMP_X] => 01/17/2019 12:57:10 am [IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [~IBLOCK_TYPE_ID] => content [LID] => en [~LID] => en [CODE] => program [~CODE] => program [NAME] => Forum program [~NAME] => Forum program [ACTIVE] => Y [~ACTIVE] => Y [SORT] => 9000 [~SORT] => 9000 [LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [~LIST_PAGE_URL] => /program/ [DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/#ELEMENT_CODE#/ [~DETAIL_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/#ELEMENT_CODE#/ [SECTION_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/ [~SECTION_PAGE_URL] => #SITE_DIR#/program/#SECTION_CODE_PATH#/ [CANONICAL_PAGE_URL] => [~CANONICAL_PAGE_URL] => [PICTURE] => [~PICTURE] => [DESCRIPTION] => [~DESCRIPTION] => [DESCRIPTION_TYPE] => text [~DESCRIPTION_TYPE] => text [RSS_TTL] => 24 [~RSS_TTL] => 24 [RSS_ACTIVE] => Y [~RSS_ACTIVE] => Y [RSS_FILE_ACTIVE] => N [~RSS_FILE_ACTIVE] => N [RSS_FILE_LIMIT] => [~RSS_FILE_LIMIT] => [RSS_FILE_DAYS] => [~RSS_FILE_DAYS] => [RSS_YANDEX_ACTIVE] => N [~RSS_YANDEX_ACTIVE] => N [XML_ID] => 900 [~XML_ID] => 900 [TMP_ID] => ff47431be7a8fb6b2d1dc2d9b1b688fb [~TMP_ID] => ff47431be7a8fb6b2d1dc2d9b1b688fb [INDEX_ELEMENT] => Y [~INDEX_ELEMENT] => Y [INDEX_SECTION] => Y [~INDEX_SECTION] => Y [WORKFLOW] => N [~WORKFLOW] => N [BIZPROC] => N [~BIZPROC] => N [SECTION_CHOOSER] => L [~SECTION_CHOOSER] => L [LIST_MODE] => [~LIST_MODE] => [RIGHTS_MODE] => S [~RIGHTS_MODE] => S [SECTION_PROPERTY] => N [~SECTION_PROPERTY] => N [PROPERTY_INDEX] => N [~PROPERTY_INDEX] => N [VERSION] => 1 [~VERSION] => 1 [LAST_CONV_ELEMENT] => 0 [~LAST_CONV_ELEMENT] => 0 [SOCNET_GROUP_ID] => [~SOCNET_GROUP_ID] => [EDIT_FILE_BEFORE] => [~EDIT_FILE_BEFORE] => [EDIT_FILE_AFTER] => [~EDIT_FILE_AFTER] => [SECTIONS_NAME] => Разделы [~SECTIONS_NAME] => Разделы [SECTION_NAME] => Раздел [~SECTION_NAME] => Раздел [ELEMENTS_NAME] => Элементы [~ELEMENTS_NAME] => Элементы [ELEMENT_NAME] => Элемент [~ELEMENT_NAME] => Элемент [EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [~EXTERNAL_ID] => 900 [LANG_DIR] => / [~LANG_DIR] => / [SERVER_NAME] => en.gaidarforum.ru [~SERVER_NAME] => en.gaidarforum.ru ) [SECTION] => Array ( [PATH] => Array ( ) ) [SECTION_URL] => [META_TAGS] => Array ( [TITLE] => EFFICIENT BUDGET EXPENDITURE AS A MIRROR OF EFFICIENT PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION [ELEMENT_CHAIN] => EFFICIENT BUDGET EXPENDITURE AS A MIRROR OF EFFICIENT PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION [BROWSER_TITLE] => [KEYWORDS] => [DESCRIPTION] => ) [EXPERTSTYPES] => Array ( [0] => OPENINGS [1] => SAY_HIS [2] => MODERATORS [3] => KEYREPORT_MODERATOR [4] => KEYREPORTS [5] => KEYREPORT2S [6] => SPEAKERS [7] => SPEECH [8] => PRESENTATIONS [9] => MEMBERS [10] => PARTICIPANTS [11] => MEMBERS_AND_EXPERTS [12] => DISCUSS_MEMBERS [13] => AUTHORS [14] => LECTORS ) [DATE_EVENT] => January 16, 2018 [START_TIME] => 10:00 [END_TIME] => 11:30 [TIME_EVENT] => January 16 [OGDESC] =>

What is public administration today? How does the budgetary system operate?

At the federal level alone there are 53 ministries and agencies (16 ministries, 19 services, 18 agencies), 373,600 people who administer more than 66% of the federal budget expenditure and at the same time generate a growing budgetary network. a multi-step public administration system gives rise to challenges within the system, reduces the control over the use of budgetary resources, and blurs responsibility for functions entrusted.

)